Brexit and the Implications for Employment Law in the UK

The UK left the EU on the 31st January 2020 following ratification by the UK and the EU of the Withdrawal Agreement. A transition period then applied until 31st December 2020. During this time for most purposes the UK was treated as if it were still a member of the EU. Therefore, most EU law continued to apply to the UK. It is the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 that ended the supremacy of EU Law in the UK and prepared the legal framework for the UK to withdraw from the EU. The Act meant a conversion of EU law into UK law as it stood at the moment of exit. Meaning that any UK Laws derived from the EU remained applicable. Therefore, this means that any employment legislation derived from the EU remains applicable in the UK, but just on a different constitutional basis.

There is now an end to the principle of the supremacy of EU law to the effect that it no longer applies to any UK enactment or rule of law passed or made on or after 31st December 2020. The supremacy of EU law continues to apply in the UK where there is an inconsistency between an EU directive and UK domestic legislation and the directive was implemented before the end of the transition period, any inconsistency in the law should be resolved in favour of the EU directive.

Regulations have been enacted that have determined that the Court of Appeal in England and Wales are not bound by retained EU case law. This does, however, raise concerns with regard to creating uncertainty in relation to employment law matters. How to interpret retained EU law since the end of the end of the transition period on 31st December 2020 is tricky to determine.

Decisions will now rest with the UK Government as to whether it should retain, amend or repeal the UK employment law that has been derived from the EU. The most likely areas of law to be subject to change are:-

  • The Working Time Directive 1998. The UK has the Working Time Regulations 1998 that govern working time and holidays. There may be an overhaul of the way holiday pay works as this is currently a complicated area due to the effects of several previous European Court of Justice decisions.
  • Agency Worker Rights – This is an area that could see an overhaul as the Agency Worker Regulations 2010 are quite complex and unpopular.
  • The Transfer of Undertakings Protection of Employees Regulations (TUPE) provide the rules for business transfers. These can be difficult to apply in practice.
  • The Equality Act 2010 – this deals with discrimination legislation in relation to workers’ protections. The Government has already indicated that it does not want to reduce the protections as set out in this legislation. However, there may be some changes to discrimination based claims.

As it is early days since Brexit only time will tell as to how exactly this will impact on the future of employment law in the UK. Watch this space …

For all employment law related advice and representation please contact Jennifer Carpenter solicitor and partner.

What Is A Deed Of Variation?

You may be surprised to learn that it is possible to alter someone’s Will after their death, providing that any beneficiaries left worse off by the changes agree. The changes can be made by what is known as a deed of variation.

If someone dies intestate (without a Will) then the intestacy rules govern who inherits. A deed of variation can also be used to change the inheritance in the same way as if there was a Will.

There are various reasons why it may be a sensible idea to change a Will or redirect inheritance under the intestacy rules. These include:-

  • to reduce the amount of Inheritance tax (IHT) or Capital Gains Tax (CGT) payable
  • to provide for someone who was left out of the Will
  • to move the deceased’s assets into a Trust
  • to clear up any uncertainty over the Will

Deeds of variation are a useful inheritance tax (IHT) planning tool because any inheritance from an estate that is redirected to others will be treated as if the deceased made the gift. This means that the person allowing the redirection does not have to survive the gift by seven years in order for it to fall outside of their own estate and therefore not be subject to IHT. A common example would be a child who is to inherit from their parent’s estate. If the child is already financially sound then they may not require the inheritance which would only increase the size of their estate, giving rise to further IHT charges on their own death. In this situation, the child may wish to redirect the inheritance to their own children who could benefit from the money.

It is important to know that a deed of variation must be made within two years of the date of death. Furthermore, once a deed of variation is signed it cannot be revoked so it is paramount that careful consideration is taken before entering into a deed of variation.

For more information, please contact our Wills and Probate department for expert and professional advice.

Adams Harrison Excellent Lexcel Audit Result July 2020

Adams Harrison is excellent – it is official.

Adams Harrison has held the Lexcel accreditation since 1999 and over the last four days has undergone a rigorous full reassessment. The result being that the firm has passed with flying colours.

What is Lexcel?

It stands for Legal Excellence and is a Law Society accreditation in relation to legal practice management standards that is optional for law firms to attain. Lexcel defines quality management procedures in seven areas: structure and strategy, financial management, information management, people management, risk management, client care, and file and case management.

During the audit there were absolutely no findings of non-compliance and the auditor identified 40 areas of good practice, an increase of four from the annual assessment last year.

The auditor for the assessment, when reporting the outcome, stated that an increase in the number of areas of good practice was a “remarkable result”, particularly in light of the recent Covid-19 pandemic.

Within the auditor’s report he has stated that the firm has a very robust and tested disaster recovery and business continuity plan. Reference was made to the firm having the Cyber Essentials kite mark.

The auditor stated that “processes and systems are extremely well understood by staff, and are also very well embedded into both the operations, and culture, of the Practice.”

In relation to risk management the finding was: “The Practice should continue to be commended for the practical, effective and comprehensive approach it has taken to operational risk management” and “the processes are clearly effective, very well implemented and, taken together, continue to constitute a highly robust approach”. It was stated that Adams Harrison should be highly commended for the work done to remain compliant against the requirements of the Standard.

The auditor was of the opinion that the Practice continues to place “very significant emphasis on the levels of ongoing client care which it provides.”

The report states that “In Lexcel terms, Adams Harrison, continues to be an extremely well run, and extremely well managed Practice – made all the more noteworthy by the fact that it has been achieved in a period of ongoing change and significant uncertainty!!”

 

Furlough Leave Update Information

All employers and organisations please be aware that in order to qualify for the subsidy from the Government’s Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme all employees/workers furloughed must have been given written instruction that they cannot do any work for the organisation that has placed them on furlough, and have consented to this in writing. This is contained in the Treasury Guidance to HMRC dated 15th April 2020.

The scheme has very recently been extended until the end of June.

For all your furlough leave questions answered, whether you are employer or employee, please contact our employment specialist Jennifer Carpenter, Solicitor and Managing Partner.

Some FAQs About Furlough Answered

Some FAQs about furlough, answered by employment law specialist, Jenny Carpenter, Solicitor.

Do you have to be employed to be placed on furlough leave?

No, the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme applies to the self employed, contractors and zero hour workers.

Can furlough leave be used for those shielding at home from Covid-19 as they are in the vulnerable group of individuals?

Yes, the Scheme Guidance makes it clear that those that are shielding in line with public health guidance can be placed on furlough leave by their employer. However, this is only the case if the employee cannot work from home and would otherwise be made redundant.

Can a worker/employee with caring responsibilities be placed on furlough leave?

Yes, if for example an employee is unable to work because there is no child care provision (particularly relevant as schools are closed) then they can volunteer for furlough leave. However, an employer is not obliged to place an employee/worker on furlough.

Can apprentices be placed on furlough leave?

Yes, and they can continue with training during this time, but not work.

Can a furloughed worker/employee undertake voluntary work whilst on furlough leave?

Yes. But not for the organisation that has placed them on furlough leave.

Can paid work be done by a worker/employee on furlough leave?

This depends. Paid work cannot be done for the organisation that placed them on furlough. However, if the worker/employee’s contract of employment permits them to have more than one job then there is no reason why they cannot take up paid work elsewhere.

Can a Nanny be placed on furlough leave?

Yes, the Guidance makes it clear that those employed by individuals can be placed on furlough. However, they must be paid through PAYE payroll and have been on the payroll as at 28th February 2020.

Can a director of a company be placed on furlough leave?

Yes, provided the decision is made by the Board of Directors and documented. It does of course mean that the director cannot then do any work for or on behalf of the Company during the period of furlough. The director can though carry out his/her statutory obligations under the Company Act 2006.

Employment Law Terms Explained

As a result of the Coronavirus pandemic we are experiencing unprecedented employment circumstances and lots of different terms are being used to describe a worker/employee’s situation:-

Laying off

The employer provides the employee with no work, nor pay for a undefined period, but retains them as an employee.

Short time working

The employer provides less work (normally less hours of work) for less pay but retains the employee.
An employer should only impose one of the above if the contract of employment makes full provision for this, otherwise the employee would have a claim for breach of contract.
In certain circumstances where an employee is put on short time working or lay off they become entitled to claim a statutory redundancy payment. This is only where the employee has at least two years continuous employment with the employer and the statutory scheme for claiming redundancy pay is followed.
To be able to claim the employee must have been laid off or kept on short-time working (or a combination of both) for at least four or more consecutive weeks; or a total of six weeks (of which no more than three are consecutive) in any period of 13 weeks.

Redundancy

A potentially fair reason to dismiss under the Employment Rights Act 1996, either due to:-

  1. A place of work closure
  2. A company/business closure
  3. There no longer being a need, or there is a reduced for employees of a particular kind.

It is worth noting, however that notice must still be given to the employee that the employment is to be terminated.

Furlough leave

With the worker/employee’s consent they agree to go on paid leave for a minimum period of three weeks whereby they do not undertake any work and are retained as an employee. The employer can utilise the Government Retention Scheme and recoup up to 80% of staff wage costs via HMRC. The employer is not obliged to pay 100% of pay during furlough leave. Forcing an employee to be furloughed would amount to breach of contract. Therefore, it can only be done with the employee’s express consent.
There is no right to request furlough leave, nor any right to request redundancy as an alternative.

For advice as an employee or employer our employment law specialist solicitor Jennifer Carpenter is available at j.carpenter@adams-harrison.co.uk.

Do I Need To Appoint A Guardian For My Children In My Will?

If you have children under 18 and you are making a Will, you should consider who would look after your children if you were to die while they are still under 18.

Writing a Will can give you peace of mind that your children will be cared for by whom you choose to look after them.

It may be that you have blood relatives who you would not want to look after your children. A Will allows you the opportunity to appoint who you would like to act as guardian for your children. You can also set out your reasons for the appointment in your Will.

If there are disagreements after your death, your Will and any additional wishes you have left would be used as evidence in court for your reasons for your appointment. Your reasons would be taken into account and carry weight with the court.

If you do not name guardians in your Wills and several potential guardians come forward, the court would have to decide to make a child arrangements order setting out with whom the child should live. The applicant who the Judge feels is best able to meet the needs of the child would be appointed. The court would need to take into account all the circumstances such as the child’s relationship with the proposed guardian and the wishes and feelings of the child him or herself in line with a child’s age and understanding.

If you were to die and the other parent of your child has parental responsibility, they would automatically become the child’s guardian irrespective of whether the parents are living together or not. If you choose someone other than the other parent with parental responsibility to be a child’s guardian in your Will, that person will not automatically become a child’s guardian. If they want to become the child’s guardian on the first parent’s death, they need to make a court application and ultimately if will be the court’s decision as to who is the best guardian to meet the children’s needs. The court will try to make a decision based on what is best for the child’s welfare using the welfare checklist which we can advise you on.

When choosing a guardian, you should consider the size of their own family and whether it would be feasible for them to take on your family. They may also not live locally which would involve a move of schools and friends for your child. They may also be older than you and within the period of guardianship may struggle to look after your children.

In your Will you can provide your guardians with additional assistance. If you own your own property; you can specify that your guardians live in your property with your children to prevent as much disruption to them as possible.

If you anticipate that your guardians would need a bigger car or would need to build an extension to their own property; you can provide a power for your executors to loan them money for this purpose.

Contracts Frustrated by COVID-19

As a result of the ongoing coronavirus pandemic issues may have, or will arise regarding the performance of contracts you may have entered into. Following the recent measures issued by the government a number of events or services have been unexpectedly cancelled. As a result of this a party may find it impossible to fulfil their obligation under the contract.

As a general rule, if performance of a contract becomes more difficult or even impossible, the party who fails to perform is liable in damages. Frustration is an exception to this rule.

In the case of Krell v Henry [1903] a situation occurred when King Edward VII fell ill with appendicitis two days before the celebrations that were to take place following his coronation. Many people had entered into contracts in advance of the celebrations, by hiring rooms to watch the procession, or boats to watch the accompanying naval review. The events were originally scheduled to take place in June of 1902, but had to be postponed until August 1902 (sound familiar to you at all?). When the celebrations were postponed, they argued that the contracts had been frustrated, and that they should not be liable for the sums they had agreed to pay. This and other cases later became known as the Coronation Cases.

What is Frustration?

Frustration is where the terms of a contract are brought to an end on the basis it is impossible to carry them out.

If a contract has been frustrated it is automatically discharged and the parties are no longer subject to their future obligations. The contract is brought to an end immediately and it is neither party’s fault. This means neither party can claim compensation even if the other party has not carried out their obligations under the contract.

When determining whether a contract has been frustrated the Courts will need to examine all the circumstance of the particular case in hand. In general terms, there are a number of conditions that must be met to determine if a contract has become frustrated.

At Adams Harrison we can advise you on contractual disputes, to include whether the contract has become frustrated, particularly in light of the current circumstances brought about by the coronavirus pandemic. Contact one of our offices to discuss how you can provide us with a copy of the contract you require advice about.

Grandparents:- Their Role, Rights And Responsibilities

The role of grandparents continues to evolve and perhaps become increasingly more important. Almost two thirds of all grandparents look after their grandchildren regularly, often whilst parents are at work. A contributory factor is the cost of childcare which means there are many informal family arrangements.

The Children Act 1989 as amended requires grandparents to seek permission (leave) of the court to file a section 8 application. This creates a two stage procedure, except in some exceptional circumstances where a grandparent may make an immediate application.

A grandparent has no parental responsibility in law which means they cannot make major decisions such as about medical treatment, schooling and for travelling outside the UK which can present difficulties for grandparents caring for their grandchildren. In the case of Re J (Leave to Issue Application for Residence Order) [2003] 1 FLR 114, Thorpe J suggested that trial judges should have greater appreciation for the contribution made by grandparents for the care of their grandchildren.

A large number of grandparents may sadly lose contact with their grandchildren when parents separate. The first step must always be to try to resolve issues within the family by agreement or through mediation.

Which court orders can grandparents apply for? The most likely court orders are a Special Guardianship Order (Section 115 of Adoption and Children Act 2002) or a Child Arrangements Order (Section 8 Children Act 1989 as amended).

  • A Special Guardianship Order lasts until a child is 18 unless changed by earlier court order. It enables the special guardian to have parental responsibility for the child and to take most decisions about the child without consulting the parent. Major decisions such as changing the child’s surname or taking them abroad for more than three months require agreement of the parents or the court’s permission. The child retains birth family links albeit that the parental responsibility of the parents is reduced.
  • A Child Arrangements Order can be granted to grandparents to confirm that the grandchild lives with them, provided they have the court’s permission to seek such an order or are exempt from doing so. A Child Arrangements Order granted to grandparent(s) can set out who the child lives with and how much time the child will spend with the parent(s) or other persons with parental responsibility.

Employment Law Changes – Are You Ready?

From 6th April 2020 all new employees, but also workers/joiners to a company, will have the right to a written statement of terms on or before the first day of employment, whereas it is currently for employees only and within two months of employment starting. This change has been brought about by an amendment to the Employment Rights Act 1996 as a result of the introduction of The Employment Rights (Employment Particulars and Paid Annual Leave)(Amendment) Regulations 2018.

Do you know what needs to be included in a written statement of terms? It does not necessarily have to be a formal contract of employment but there is prescribed information that must be provided, much sooner than previously and now to workers as well as employees.

There is a right for employees and workers to bring Employment Tribunal claims if the organisation engaging them fails to do this.

The Government has said that the intention is to ensure that workers can access fair and decent work, that both employers and workers have clarity on the employment relationship, and that the enforcement system is fair and fit for purpose. Above all, the direction of travel is to protect vulnerable workers and improve workers’ understanding of their rights.

The best way to ensure compliance is to have a properly drafted contract of employment that is ready to pass to a worker or employee at the latest on the day they start work. If you ask us to prepare the contract we can include all the requirements and information that an employer is obliged to give. The new Regulations include additional information that must now be provided. For example, probationary period details and days of the week worked must be provided for those starting work after 6th April.

There is information that the Regulations state the employer can choose whether to put in the main written statement of terms (contract) or in “reasonably accessible document(s)” but the following information must be provided:-

  • Terms for absence due to incapacity and sickness and the position regarding sick pay.
  • The notice periods for termination.
  • Information relating to grievances and disciplinary.
  • Terms relating to pensions and pension schemes.

Even if there is not a legal requirement to contain certain information in the written statement of terms it may be advisable to have additional terms to protect your business, for example post termination restrictions.

Contact us to arrange an appointment with Jenny Carpenter, specialist employment solicitor and partner to discuss your requirements.